How Our Consignment Process Works
We are currently accepting spring consignments.
We accept consignments Mon - Fri 10AM-4:00PM. We look at 20 items per visit. Clothing must be on hangers (we return hangers to you).
Once your items sell you receive 50% of the selling price. Items are displayed for sale for 60 days.
Stop in once per calendar month to pick up the money you've made! Checks can be mailed upon request for a small fee.
About Us
On Second Thought Consignment is Lynchburg's premier consignment shop. Since opening in 2004, On Second Thought has grown to 8,000 square feet, selling gently used women's clothing, accessories, home decor, furniture, and more. We are regularly voted Best Consignment Shop by Lynchburg Living Magazine. On Second Thought Consignment is proud to be locally owned and operated!
We're Moving!
After over 20 years we have outgrown our current location and are moving! We will be right across the street in a brand new building. You can expect more space to shop, more dressing rooms, and a streamlined customer experience. Did we mention our women's clothing store and home furnishings store will be under one roof?! Follow us on social media for updates!
What Our Customers Are Saying
"I love this store for the friendliness of the staff and good quality of merchandise they carry. I consign with them as well and they handle my items very professionally and quickly process them. So glad they are in business because I get great deals there." - Nancy Y.
"My favorite store in town! A cheerful and attractive place to shop and I always find name brand clothes - Ann Taylor, Talbot’s, Chico’s - at affordable prices. The home furnishings store is a delight as well. There are new treasures to discover every time I go." - Kathryn T.
Gift Cards Available!
Gifting is simple with a gift card to On Second Thought Consignment! Gift cards can be purchased in-store at either location (women's clothing or home decor).