On Second Thought Consignment was founded in 2004 and is the premier consignment shop in Lynchburg, Virginia. What started out as a small shop has grown four times in size to 8,000 square feet. Our customer base has grown just as quickly and we now have over 13,000 people who trust us to sell thousands of their items every week. We are regularly voted Best Lynchburg Consignment Shop. The recipe for our success is simple:

  • Accept only the highest quality merchandise into inventory to guarantee the quality of your shopping experience.
  • We use computerized inventory tracking and customer accounting. This allows us to accurately track your account and provide quick payouts.
  • Selected items, which remain in inventory past their contract period, are considered for donation to a local charity.
  • Shopping at our Lynchburg consignment shop is an enjoyable experience. The store is clean, spacious and well lit. Inventory is organized and merchandised with displays to help sell your items fast.

From women’s clothing and accessories to furniture and home décor, On Second Thought Consignment provides its loyal customers with great merchandise at even better prices. We invite you to visit us, whether to shop or consign, and become a part of our journey to provide the community with a fun and affordable shopping experience.